ADOLESCENT PSYCH
| Matthew Westra |
(Fall 2004)
|
THE SELF & IDENTITY FORMATION
READING: "Trashing Teens"
from Psychology Today
IDENTITY
Classical Issue of Adolescence - the search for IDENTITY
Just to ask, "Who am I?" is to view the Self as a product.
To be able to answer this is to lock yourself in time and space.
It also assumes that there is a unified and consistent "I" that does
not change.
Perhaps it is better phrased as 3 questions:
1. Who was I?
2. Who am I now?
3. Who am I becoming?
Alice Through the Looking Glass
"Who are you." said the
caterpillar.
This was not an encouraging opening for
a conversation.
Alice replied rather shyly, "I hardly
know,
sir, just at present - at least I knew who I was when I got up this
morning,
but I think I must have changed several times since then."
ERIKSON - Identity vs. Identity Diffusion
Recently split off by Newman & Newman to 2 substages:
Early Adolescence (12-18)
Later Adolescence (18-22+)
Early Adolescence (12-18) Group Identity vs.
Alienation
- Central Process for Resolution of Psychosocial Crisis is
Peer
Pressure
- Developmental Tasks: Physical Maturation, Formal
Operations,
Emotional Development, Membership in peer groups, Establish,
Develop
& Maintain Sexual relationships (loosely defined - dating, going
steady,
etc.)
- Prime Adaptive Ego Quality - Fidelity 1, "The ability to
freely
pledge and sustain loyalty to others."
- Core Pathology - Isolation, "Reduced or absent social
contact or
connection."
Later Adolescence (18-24+) Individual Identity vs.
Identity
Confusion
- Central Process for Resolution of Psychosocial Crisis is
Role
Exploration
- Developmental Tasks: Autonomy in relation to parents,
Sex-role identity,
Internalized Morality, Career Choice.
- Prime Adaptive Ego Quality - Fidelity 2, "The ability
to
freely
pledge and sustain loyalty to values & ideologies."
- Core Pathology - Repudiation, "Rejection of roles and
values
that
seem alien to oneself."
Marcia's Identity Statuses
James Marcia identified four types of adolescent
identity statuses. Each was based on whether the individual made a
commitment to the identity and whether there had been an identity
crisis in the process of getting there.
The identity crisis involves a deep and profound
questioning of one's place in the world, values, beliefs, mission
and purpose, and world view. Such crises don't happen to everyone, yet
some people may have them at different times in life, particularly
adolescence and mid-life.
Marcia's 4
Identity Statuses are:
- Identity Confusion - No
identity crisis has been experienced and no commitments to an identity
have been made.
- Identity Foreclosed - No
identity crisis has been experienced, but commitments to an
identity have been made, usually forced on the person by the
parent(s).
- Identity Moratorium - Considerable
identity
crisis
is being experienced,
but no commitments to an identity are yet
made.
- Identity Achieved - Numerous
identity
crises
have been experienced and
resolved, and relatively permanent commitments to an identity
have been made.
2 Central Issues in
Marcia:
- Presence
or Absence of an Identity Crisis.
It is vital to note that Marcia is referring to a crisis of identity,
an experience in which the person must re-consider her/his sense of
self and relation to others. This is a process, and often a long one,
in which powerful questions are asked and meaningful answers are
sought. (Note: this does NOT refer to situational crises, such as
divorce or death of a family member.)
- Presence
or Absence of a Commitment
to Identity.
People make many types of commitments in life. The Commitment to
Identity that Marcia presents is the result of solidifying one's sense
of self, values, purposes, beliefs, and relations to others and the
world in general. Commitment can result from a personal search for
identity which results in satisfying answers to these issues of Self,
or the commitment can be ascribed to a person by external forces such
as family, culture, etc.
|
Explor
|
ation |
| Commitment |
High |
Low |
| High |
Identity Achievement
(with identity crisis) |
Foreclosure
(no identity crisis) |
| Low |
Moratorium
(with identity crisis) |
Identity Diffusion
(no identity crisis) |
IDENTITY RELATED TO LIFE PLAN
Identity - Deciding "Who I am" is connected to self-selecting one's
FATE.
We create criteria
for the Self:
I AM.... (discuss the exercise - write 20 variations on
finishing
the sentence)
How do we go about fulfilling the dictates of our
Created/Discovered
Identities?
FAMILY DYNAMICS
In Family Systems Theory, there is the notion that:
- because we gain much of our IDENTITY from our PARENTS,
- we are likely to DUPLICATE PARENTS'
- BEHAVIOR and
- LIFE CHOICES.
CROSS-CULTURE - NATIVE AMERICANS
VISION QUEST
Many Native American Tribes have historically determined a boy's
identity
through such means as the Vision Quest.
- Purification - sweat lodge, fasting, etc.
- Solitude - Go alone into the wilderness.
- Sacrifice - of things, of self
- Perception Alteration:
Sacred Drugs (Peyote, etc.)
Suffering - fasting, exhaustion, self-induced pain.
Calling for Spirit Guide - Animal or Plant to Mentor the
boy.
Vision - Spirit Guide Appears, pledges to guide boy, tells
boy
of life themes.
Return to Village - tell of the vision
Pursue Life Themes, Rely on Spirit Guide
SELF ESTEEM
Essential Question: "Should people have Self Esteem just
because
they ARE, or should they have to BE and/or DO something WORTH
esteeming?
Coopersmith (1967)
Coopersmith worked with
12 year old boys (gender bias?).
Found 4 factors that
contributed
to Self Concept:
- Significance - how much a person is loved and
approved of
by others.
- Competence - how well does a person perform tasks
he
or she
considers to be important.
- Virtue - to what extent does a person feel he or
she
has
attained the expected moral standards of their culture.
- Power - how well and to what extent can a person
control
him/herself and his/her influence on others.
Those possessing these qualities had higher self
esteem.
To help foster self esteem, Coopersmith suggested:
- Keep your own esteem high.
- Communicate concern and interest to the child.
- Encourage interaction with the child.
- Engage in joint activities.
- Use reinforcement rather than punishment to enforce rules.
- Encourage self-reliance and independent behavior tempered with
protection
from too much pressure.
SELF ESTEEM RELATED TO BIOLOGY
Consider: How could Self Esteem be the result of Innate, or
Biological
factors?
Some Answers:
- Physically (un)attractive features
- Temperament - often believed to be inborn.
- Depression - generally identified as having
biological (inherited)
components. Runs in families, adoption studies support genetic
predisposition.
- Bipolar (I & II) - Mood Swings effect self
ratings.
- High Self Esteem self-reports when cycling to good
feelings.
- Low Self Esteem self-reports when cycling to depressed
feelings.