ADOLESCENT PSYCH
Return to Syllabus
Return to Westra's Home Page
Matthew Westra
(Fall 2004)
 THE SELF & IDENTITY FORMATION

READING:    "Trashing Teens" from Psychology Today 


IDENTITY

Classical Issue of Adolescence - the search for IDENTITY
Just to ask, "Who am I?" is to view the Self as a product.
To be able to answer this is to lock yourself in time and space.
It also assumes that there is a unified and consistent "I" that does not change.

Perhaps it is better phrased as 3 questions:
            1. Who was I?
            2. Who am I now?
            3. Who am I becoming?

Alice Through the Looking Glass

"Who are you." said the caterpillar.
This was not an encouraging opening for a conversation.
Alice replied rather shyly, "I hardly know, sir, just at present - at least I knew who I was when I got up this morning, but I think I must have changed several times since then."

ERIKSON - Identity vs. Identity Diffusion
Recently split off by Newman & Newman to 2 substages:
            Early Adolescence (12-18)
            Later Adolescence (18-22+)

Early Adolescence (12-18) Group Identity vs. Alienation

Later Adolescence (18-24+) Individual Identity vs. Identity Confusion  
Marcia's Identity Statuses

 James Marcia identified four types of adolescent identity statuses. Each was based on whether the individual made a commitment to the identity and whether there had been an identity crisis in the process of getting there.
    The identity crisis involves a deep and profound questioning of  one's place in the world, values, beliefs, mission and purpose, and world view. Such crises don't happen to everyone, yet some people may have them at different times in life, particularly adolescence and mid-life.

    Marcia's 4 Identity Statuses are:

    2 Central Issues in Marcia:
  1. Presence or Absence of an Identity Crisis.
    It is vital to note that Marcia is referring to a crisis of identity, an experience in which the person must re-consider her/his sense of self and relation to others. This is a process, and often a long one, in which powerful questions are asked and meaningful answers are sought. (Note: this does NOT refer to situational crises, such as divorce or death of a family member.)
  2. Presence or Absence of a Commitment to Identity. 
    People make many types of commitments in life. The Commitment to Identity that Marcia presents is the result of solidifying one's sense of self, values, purposes, beliefs, and relations to others and the world in general. Commitment can result from a personal search for identity which results in satisfying answers to these issues of Self, or the commitment can be ascribed to a person by external forces such as family, culture, etc.
 

Explor
ation
Commitment High Low
High Identity Achievement
(with identity crisis)
Foreclosure
(no identity crisis)
Low Moratorium
(with identity crisis)
Identity Diffusion
(no identity crisis)



IDENTITY RELATED TO LIFE PLAN
Identity - Deciding "Who I am" is connected to self-selecting one's FATE.
         We create criteria for the Self:
I AM.... (discuss the exercise - write 20 variations on finishing the sentence)
How do we go about fulfilling the dictates of our Created/Discovered Identities?

FAMILY DYNAMICS

In Family Systems Theory, there is the notion that:



CROSS-CULTURE - NATIVE AMERICANS

VISION QUEST



SELF ESTEEM

Essential Question: "Should people have Self Esteem just because they ARE, or should they have to BE and/or DO something WORTH esteeming?

Coopersmith (1967)
        Coopersmith worked with 12 year old boys (gender bias?).
        Found 4 factors that contributed to Self Concept:

  1. Significance - how much a person is loved and approved of by others.
  2. Competence - how well does a person perform tasks he or she considers to be important.
  3. Virtue - to what extent does a person feel he or she has attained the expected moral  standards of their culture.
  4. Power - how well and to what extent can a person control him/herself and his/her  influence on others.
    Those possessing these qualities had higher self esteem.

To help foster self esteem, Coopersmith suggested:

  1. Keep your own esteem high.
  2. Communicate concern and interest to the child.
  3. Encourage interaction with the child.
  4. Engage in joint activities.
  5. Use reinforcement rather than punishment to enforce rules.
  6. Encourage self-reliance and independent behavior tempered with protection from too much pressure.
SELF ESTEEM RELATED TO BIOLOGY
Consider:  How could Self Esteem be the result of Innate, or Biological factors?

Some Answers:


December 13, 2010